Best Nantucket Restaurants 2023: The Ultimate Top 20 Guide

Family eating on Nantucket

20 Best Nantucket Restaurants and Cafes 2023

Nantucket is an island located off the coast of Massachusetts known for its beautiful beaches, historic architecture, and excellent cuisine. As a food lover, you will be pleased to know that there are many fantastic restaurants on the island, each offering a unique culinary experience.

Top 20 best restaurants and cafes on Nantucket that you should try in 2023:

  1. TOPPER'S: Located at The Wauwinet, TOPPER'S is one of the best Nantucket restaurants in 2023. Offering a refined and sophisticated dining experience. The restaurant features an extensive wine list and a menu featuring the freshest seafood and local produce.

  2. STRAIGHT WHARF RESTAURANT: With stunning views of Nantucket Harbor, Straight Wharf Restaurant is a must-visit for seafood lovers. The menu features local and sustainable ingredients, including the freshest fish and shellfish.

  3. THE PEARL: Under new ownership, The Pearl has a menu focused on coastal Asian renewal, inspired by a 30-year maritime legacy with a nod towards the future. It will remain one of the best Nantucket restaurants in 2023. 

  4. PI PIZZERIA: Pi Pizzeria serves authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and delicious Italian American cuisine. PI prepares the food using the time-honored methods of traditional Italian cooking. Their dough is made fresh each morning, the sauce is made from scratch using imported San Marzano tomatoes and our whole milk mozzarella cheese is grated fresh each day. The pizza toppings are what you would find in a traditional Neapolitan pizzeria. The pizzas are cooked at 900 degrees in Nantucket’s only commercial wood fired oven. Each evening PI offers additions to our dinner menu that are driven by local and seasonal ingredients. Visit Pi Pizzeria and experience a taste of Naples Italy for one of the best pizza restaurants on Nantucket in 2023. 

  5. GALLEY BEACH: Galley Beach is one of the most romantic restaurants on the island, featuring breathtaking ocean views and a menu highlighting fresh, local ingredients. The restaurant is a perfect place to watch the sunset while enjoying delicious cuisine.

  6. THE NAUTILUS: The Nautilus is a contemporary seafood restaurant with a fun and lively atmosphere. The menu features creative dishes and an impressive raw bar selection.

  7. LOBSTER TRAP: As the name suggests, Lobster Trap is a seafood-focused restaurant known for its fresh lobster and other seafood dishes. The restaurant also offers an extensive wine list and creative cocktails.

  8. DUNE: Dune is a popular restaurant serving contemporary American cuisine with a focus on local and sustainable ingredients. The menu features creative dishes that showcase the best of Nantucket's culinary scene.

  9. SLIP 14: Slip 14 is a casual seafood restaurant located on the docks of Nantucket Harbor. The restaurant features a fun and lively atmosphere and a menu highlighting fresh seafood, including lobster rolls and fish tacos.

  10. CRU: CRU is a chic and stylish restaurant located on Straight Wharf, offering stunning harbor views and a menu featuring the freshest seafood and local ingredients.

  11. BLACK EYED SUSAN'S:  Tel:508.325.0308 10 India Street Nantucket MA 02554  Black Eyed Susan's is a cozy restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The menu features classic American dishes with a creative twist, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting.

  12. THE CHANTICLEER: The Chanticleer is a fine-dining restaurant located in a historic house on the island. The menu features French-inspired cuisine, and the wine list is extensive.

  13. BOARDING HOUSE: Boarding House is a popular restaurant located in a historic building in the heart of downtown Nantucket. The menu features New American cuisine, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming.

  14. FOG ISLAND CAFE: Fog Island Cafe is a casual restaurant serving breakfast and lunch, located in the heart of Nantucket's historic district. The menu features classic American dishes with a focus on fresh, local ingredients.

  15. NANTUCKET TOWN: Nantucket Town is a contemporary American restaurant located in downtown Nantucket. The menu features creative dishes made with local and sustainable ingredients, and the atmosphere is relaxed and casual.

  16. PROVISIONS: Provisions is a gourmet market and cafe located in the heart of downtown Nantucket. The menu features delicious sandwiches, salads, and baked goods, and the market offers a wide selection of specialty foods and wines.

  17. AMERICAN SEASONS: American Seasons is a contemporary American restaurant located in the heart of downtown Nantucket. The menu features creative dishes made with the freshest ingredients, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting.

  18. THE BEET: The Beet is a collaboration of Amy Young and Felino Samson, two hospitality pros that share a passion for good food, fun atmospheres, and colorful travel adventures. They felt there was a niche for welcoming, healthy food, in a relaxed style on Nantucket. They merged their fine dining experience with our laid back personalities to create something unique on Nantucket.
    Felino channels his Filipino heritage and love of travel to create a menu that brings the bold flavors of Latin + Asian cuisines to the Nantucket dining scene. Try something new or indulge in few of your Beet favorites as our full menu is served 'all day'. 

  19. NANTUCKET ISLAND KITCHEN: Island Kitchen is a beloved restaurant located on the picturesque island of Nantucket, off the coast of Massachusetts. With its coastal charm and laid-back atmosphere, Island Kitchen has become a popular destination for both locals and visitors alike.
    The restaurant's menu features fresh and locally sourced ingredients, with an emphasis on seafood. From classic New England clam chowder to buttery lobster rolls, Island Kitchen's menu has something for everyone. In addition to their seafood offerings, they also have delicious vegetarian and gluten-free options available.
    Island Kitchen's interior is designed with a nod to the island's classic New England style. With white beadboard walls, light wood accents, and nautical decor, the restaurant is both inviting and relaxing. They also have a beautiful outdoor patio, perfect for dining al fresco on warm summer days.
    Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner, Island Kitchen is the perfect spot. Their friendly staff and delicious food make for an unforgettable dining experience. So next time you're on Nantucket, be sure to stop by Island Kitchen for a taste of the island's best cuisine.

  20.  Lemon Press: Organic Eatery: Lemon Press is a Persian restaurant in Nantucket's Downtown historic district inspired by the owners heritage and upbringing. The menu offers unique and flavorful dishes.   

The Wauwinet is home to one of the Nantucket's best restaurants in 2023, TOPPER'S. Set alongside the waters of Nantucket Bay, this foodie destination showcases seasonally inspired New England cuisine with an emphasis on local produce and seafood. Try oysters on the half shell, locally harvested 300 yards away, paired with a cocktail or one of our 1,550 wines and rare vintages.

Wauwinet Lady boat to Toppers Restaurant
 Wauwinet Lady arriving at Toppers Restaurant ​​
Wauwinet Resort and Toppers Restaurant
Arial view of ​​Wauwinet Resort and Toppers Restaurant

There's nothing better than cruising the Nantucket Bay on a sunny day or a balmy evening. Hop on board The Wauwinet Lady, a 20 passenger boat, and take in the island's breathtaking scenery. Cruise over to TOPPER'S restaurant for lunch and dinner on the outdoor deck with stunning bay views. This is the place to be this summer season.